Will Supporting Mental Health Stop Gun Violence? Sadly, No.

Will Supporting Psychological Well being Cease Gun Violence? Sadly, No.


Within the wake of one other horrific mass taking pictures, the U.S. Senate handed the primary main federal gun security laws in many years. This rapidly cleared the U.S. Home and President Biden signed The Safer Communities Act into regulation on June 25, 2022. A significant a part of this bipartisan invoice is tens of millions in funding for psychological well being.

Certainly, at any time when there’s a name to do one thing about gun violence, many level to psychological well being as the issue. The NRA’s response to the invoice was a name to repair “our severely damaged psychological well being system.” It is a frequent response. After two mass shootings in Texas in 2019, then-President Trump stated that “psychological sickness and hatred pull the set off.” Many leaders stated the identical after this yr’s Uvalde faculty taking pictures. For instance, Texas Gov. Greg Abbott’s response was that “we as a society have to do a greater job with psychological well being … anybody who shoots anyone else has a psychological well being problem, interval.”

This response is comprehensible, because it appears frequent sense that no “regular” particular person would choose up a gun and begin taking pictures harmless individuals. However is it true? As you would possibly count on, the reality is extra difficult.

Price of Violence and Psychological Well being

There are two questions, actually. First, are individuals with psychological diseases extra more likely to commit an act of gun violence? That query is necessary, however so is the reverse: When an act of gun violence is dedicated, is the perpetrator more likely to have a psychological dysfunction? In brief, the reply to the primary query is “sure, a bit,” however the reply to the second is “no.”

First, are individuals with psychological sickness extra violent than others? It is a little simpler to reply of the 2 questions as we will comply with sufferers with psychological sickness with some accuracy. One research, for instance, adopted virtually a thousand sufferers discharged from a psychiatric hospital. They discovered that about 2 p.c of these individuals dedicated an act of gun violence, and about half of these have been towards strangers. This doesn’t imply that 2 p.c of mentally sick individuals will probably be violent—most individuals with a psychological sickness by no means get hospitalized. So we’re primarily speaking about individuals with critical psychological diseases. And another research recommend that some extreme problems are the most definitely to be violent, corresponding to schizophrenia and substance use problems. This appears to make sense—individuals with schizophrenia might develop into paranoid and really feel others are persecuting them, so we will think about that they might develop into violent out of a mistaken perception that they’re at risk. Equally, individuals who abuse alcohol and different substances lose a lot of their self-control, making them extra more likely to resort to violence.

However once we say they’re extra more likely to commit violence than others, how probably is that? Not very. The chance of an individual with schizophrenia committing murder is about 0.3%. Meaning lower than 1 in 300 individuals identified with schizophrenia are more likely to commit homicide. The numbers are just like substance use, which means that although you possibly can say that individuals with these issues are extra harmful than these with out, virtually all of the individuals with these problems will not be more likely to shoot anybody.

Anger Might Gas Most Gun Deaths

Given how small that quantity is, mixed with how uncommon the problems are (schizophrenia impacts about 1 p.c of the inhabitants, substance use about 10 p.c), you don’t must be a mathematician to determine this can not presumably account for all of the gun violence in our nation. That is significantly true when you keep in mind that most acts of gun violence will not be the tragic mass shootings we see within the media. The Facilities for Illness Management tells us that in 2020, 19,384 individuals have been murdered by weapons. Most we by no means hear about. They don’t seem to be mass shootings however home arguments, bar fights, gang violence, and different nonetheless tragic however much less newsworthy killings.

So though we keep in mind dramatic instances like that of Jared Lee Loughner, who shot 19 individuals in Tucson in 2011, there are far too many gun killings and much too few individuals like Loughner to trigger all of those killings.

Research gun violence discover that the majority offenders don’t have any historical past of a psychological dysfunction. Lower than 10 p.c of gun murderers have a historical past of schizophrenia. For mass shootings, the quantity is a bit larger, about 20 p.c, however that also means 80 p.c of mass shooters do not need schizophrenia. Substance use is extra frequent, and even when the shooter didn’t have a historical past of substance use, they typically drank or used a drug on the time of the crime. Nonetheless, most homicides don’t contain individuals with a recognized historical past of substance use dysfunction. They’re, as arduous as it’s to think about, simply “regular,” however very indignant individuals carrying a simple technique to kill somebody.

Different Deaths by Violence

Nevertheless, there may be one kind of violence for which psychological problems are very a lot an issue. That’s suicide. Sufferers with schizophrenia, substance use problems, main melancholy, bipolar dysfunction, and plenty of different problems have a a lot larger danger of dying by suicide than others.

So after I hear a name for psychological well being help after each tragic taking pictures, I really feel blended. We’d like extra psychological well being help as a result of individuals with psychological sickness are struggling, and too many are dying. However will this remedy our nation’s downside with gun violence? No.

In regards to the Creator

Robert J. Boland, MD, is the Chief of Workers and a Senior Vice President at The Menninger Clinic. He’s additionally Vice Chair of the Menninger Division of Psychiatry and Behavioral Science at Baylor School of Drugs (BCM) and the Brown Basis Endowed Chair in Psychiatry at BCM. He’s additionally the co-host of The Menninger Clinic’s Thoughts Dive Podcast, which examines dilemmas confronted by psychological well being professionals.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *