Misconceptions About the Link Between Psychosis and Violence

Misconceptions Concerning the Hyperlink Between Psychosis and Violence


An inquiry has been commissioned after a person with paranoid schizophrenia who had misplaced contact with psychological well being providers killed a stranger in a vacation city with a throwing knife.

A paranoid schizophrenic who killed three pensioners within the house of some hours in Exeter, has been discovered not responsible of homicide by purpose of madness… (He) was affected by delusions that led him to wrongly imagine he was uncovering a paedophile ring, his trial heard. @ 2021 Jackie Craissati.

This was on the primary web page of the search engine once I typed in “psychiatric affected person kills,” two horrible tragedies reported by U.Ok. nationwide newspapers; observe the theme of frenzied knife use, terrifyingly surprising assaults that intrude on the sufferer’s on a regular basis life, and the implication that psychological well being providers had failed ultimately.

The query is whether or not media reporting displays a painful actuality concerning the nature of extreme psychological sickness or is selling myths concerning the nature of insanity— demonizing individuals whose “otherness” is alien to us and due to this fact scary.


Psychosis is a generic time period used for a state by which an individual perceives or interprets actuality in a different way from the individuals round them, such that s/he could possibly be described as having “misplaced contact with actuality.”

It might embrace situations that vary from a transient episode triggered by heavy unlawful drug use, for instance, to an everlasting situation which may entice the prognosis of schizophrenia or essentially the most extreme type of despair.

The signs of psychosis that most people may be most accustomed to are hallucinations (for instance, voices) and delusions (false beliefs) though figuring out whether or not or not these “signs” mirror an underlying sickness course of is on no account simple.

Key Details

These are some completely key information about violence to others and psychosis:

  • Solely about 10 p.c of these with psychosis are violent to others, which is about 5 instances better than the chance of violence within the normal inhabitants. Nearly all of this enhance in danger might be accounted for by problematic substance misuse fairly than the psychosis alone.
  • About three in 1,000 people with psychosis kill others; this tiny however nonetheless tragic variety of incidents is round 15 instances better than the chance within the normal inhabitants. Nevertheless, it’s the identical charge of murder as in those that have problematic substance misuse however no psychosis.

If we take into account violence turned towards self—that’s, suicide—then the figures change into very stark certainly:

  • There’s a 6 p.c danger of somebody with psychosis taking their life over the course of their lifetime, and in anyone yr, round 30 p.c of suicides are people beneath the care of psychological well being providers.
  • Substance misuse is clear in greater than 50 p.c of this subgroup of suicides.

When studying these dry statistics, it’s straightforward to lose the humanity that lies behind the figures. But each act of violence dedicated by people fighting their psychological well being issues— whether or not directed towards others or themselves—is a tragedy that carries in its wake waves of trauma, misery, and anger for victims and perpetrators, for households, buddies, and communities.

Nonetheless, our distorted understanding of the character of the chance is perpetuated by surprising media accounts. In truth, there are two key however sobering information to carry in thoughts:

  • First, somebody with psychosis is round 33 instances extra more likely to take their very own life than the lifetime of one other.
  • Second, the chance issue that’s actually driving these tragedies is primarily substance misuse; by addressing the heavy use of medicine and alcohol, we are going to actually begin to make a distinction within the issues about psychosis and violence.

Should you or somebody you like is considering suicide, search assist instantly. For assist 24/7 contact the Nationwide Suicide Prevention Lifeline, at 1-800-273-TALK, or attain out to the Disaster Textual content Line by texting TALK to 741741. To discover a therapist close to you, go to the Psychology As we speak Remedy Listing.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *