Hallucinated Colors Produce Real Color Afterimages

Hallucinated Colours Produce Actual Coloration Afterimages


One of many earliest discoveries in perceptual psychology was the existence of coloration afterimages. For instance, the sq. under on the precise is clearly white. However in the event you first stare on the crimson sq. for about 30 seconds after which look on the sq. on the precise, it’s best to expertise a greenish-blue or cyan afterimage.

Source: Nicolas Davidenko

If you happen to stare on the crimson sq. for 30 seconds after which take a look at the white sq., it ought to seem bluish-green or cyan.

Supply: Nicolas Davidenko

The invention of such coloration afterimages (or aftereffects) was extremely consequential in our understanding of coloration processing, main Ewald Hering to develop the opponent-process idea in 1878 – the concept we course of colours through opponent channels that reply positively or negatively to opposing pairs of colours (e.g., crimson vs. inexperienced, blue vs. yellow, and white vs. black). These opponent channels have lengthy been regarded as applied on the earliest phases of visible processing within the retina itself.

Nonetheless, a brand new analysis examine printed in Notion by Oksana Sivkovich Fagin and Arien Mack challenges this assumption. The researchers used hypnosis to indicate that coloration afterimages might be produced solely by higher-level cortical mechanisms. Of their first experiment, 100 individuals have been screened for suggestibility utilizing the Harvard Group Scale of Hypnotic Suggestibility: Kind A (Shor & Orne, 1962).

Fifteen individuals have been chosen as being extremely suggestible. These individuals underwent hypnotic induction and have been informed that after they opened their eyes, they might see a crimson display. The truth is, the display was at all times grey.

As soon as the hypnotized individuals confirmed they have been seeing crimson, they have been instructed to maintain trying on the “crimson” display for an additional 30 seconds. Afterward, a brand new, barely lighter grey display appeared, and individuals have been requested to rapidly identify the colour they noticed. The placing end result was that of the 11 individuals who reported seeing crimson throughout the hypnotic induction, ten of them reported the colour of the second grey display as being inexperienced or blue, in keeping with what can be skilled as an actual afterimage of crimson.

The 4 individuals who didn’t hallucinate crimson didn’t report any coloration afterimage in any respect. Importantly, solely three of the eleven individuals who hallucinated crimson knew that its aftereffect was imagined to be inexperienced, though all of them reported the aftereffect as bluish somewhat than greenish. This implies that the outcomes will not be prone to be pushed by particiapnts’ prior information about coloration afterimages.

Hallucination is distinct from psychological imagery.

In a follow-up experiment, the researchers examined whether or not comparable afterimages can be produced if individuals merely imagined a coloration with out present process hypnosis first. Utilizing an analogous process, the researchers screened 150 new individuals to pick the 15 most suggestible. These individuals didn’t bear hypnosis however have been merely instructed to think about crimson when trying on the first grey display for 30 seconds.

Then, when a second grey display was introduced, they reported any coloration they noticed. Though all 15 individuals reported being profitable at imagining crimson, solely 5 of them reported seeing a blue or inexperienced aftereffect within the second grey display; one other 5 individuals reported seeing pink (inconsistent with a coloration afterimage), and the remaining 5 reported seeing only a shade of grey. A statistical evaluation confirmed that the hypnotized group within the first experiment skilled blue/inexperienced coloration afterimages considerably greater than the non-hypnotized group.

The outcomes of this analysis are groundbreaking as a result of they exhibit that actual coloration afterimages might be produced within the absence of actual coloration adaptation. Which means the opponent channels thought to account for coloration afterimages can’t exist solely within the retina however should additionally manifest at greater ranges of cortical processing that may be engaged by hypnotic suggestion.

Nonetheless, the examine leaves some questions open for future analysis. For instance, with actual coloration adaptation, we all know that longer intervals of adaptation result in stronger coloration afterimages. Is identical factor true for hallucinated colours? In different phrases, does hallucinating crimson for 60 seconds produce stronger or longer-lasting coloration aftereffects than hallucinating crimson for simply 15 seconds? In that case, it will present additional proof that the mechanisms of hallucinated coloration adaptation are much like the mechanisms of actual coloration adaptation.

The analysis examine additionally leaves open the query of what occurs on the neural degree when somebody is hypnotized to see a coloration that is not there. An earlier examine by Kosslyn et al. (2000) examined mind activations when extremely suggestible individuals have been both requested to think about a coloration or hypnotized to hallucinate a coloration. When imagining a coloration, individuals confirmed activation in the precise hemisphere coloration space.

However when hallucinating a coloration, each the precise and left hemisphere coloration areas have been activated, much like what occurs when an actual coloration is introduced. This implies that bilateral activation of coloration processing areas within the mind is important so as to induce coloration afterimages. Whether or not these bilateral activations might be induced with out hypnosis is a query for future analysis.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *