Does Removing Criminal Penalties for Drug Use Lead to More Drug Use?

Does Eradicating Prison Penalties for Drug Use Result in Extra Drug Use?


Judge holds papers

The talk over drug legalization has gone on for years, with little progress being made in the direction of a compromise that meets the pursuits of all sides. On the one hand, some individuals assist the thought of fully legalizing all medication or, on the very least, decriminalizing them. Nevertheless, if medication are authorized, it’s fairly protected to imagine that extra individuals will use them since they are going to be extra accessible and gained’t carry such a detrimental connotation. If the purpose is to create a drug-free society, it doesn’t appear that making medication extra accessible is the precise method to go.

On the different aspect of the spectrum, some individuals assist the thought of continuous with the present system, which is to criminalize individuals for utilizing medication. Nevertheless, virtually 50 years of Warfare on Medicine insurance policies have fully failed to scale back drug use in America with drug statistics worsening annually, not enhancing. In the meantime, the criminalization of drug habit has resulted in a bloated prison justice system and the biggest jail inhabitants on the planet.

The purpose, after all, have to be to scale back drug use and assist addicts get higher, not criminalize them. However it’s unlikely that the present method or a blanket legalization method will accomplish this purpose. It could be attainable {that a} compromise may create a greater state of affairs. Such a system would decriminalize drug use to some extent whereas nonetheless leaving sure penalties in place that may act as incentives for addicts to hunt therapy.

Maybe the answer is neither 100% legalization nor 100% criminalization, fairly a rigorously constructed system that makes use of some penalties for transgressions whereas constantly supporting, encouraging, and insisting on therapy.

Analyzing Each Arguments

Cannabis store

Some proof means that legalizing hashish led to extra hashish use within the states that legalized it. Additional, some proof additionally means that using different medication, akin to opioids, additionally went up in states that legalized them. Granted, opioid use has been going up throughout the nation, which makes it not possible to establish if the surge in opioid abuse in these states is the impact of hashish legalization.

Individuals who oppose legalization additionally argue that drug use and crime go hand-in-hand. Nevertheless, this aspect of the argument is probably going nullified in a proposed world the place all medication are authorized. Nonetheless, drug use is immensely dangerous irrespective of the authorized context, and even when medication have been authorized, addicts would nonetheless undergo, individuals who use medication would nonetheless die, and habit would nonetheless smash households.

Conversely, some proof suggests drug decriminalization and/or legalization makes therapy extra out there for addicts, reduces drug use, considerably reduces the stigma related to habit, and shifts the general public focus concerning habit to considered one of habit being a well being situation, not a prison inclination. With the purpose being the therapy of habit and the restoration of those that undergo from drug abuse, a extra compassionate and health-oriented method to habit could be a useful improvement.

Sadly, in locations within the U.S. the place decriminalization or legalization have been piloted, there have been blended outcomes at finest. The newest instance is in Oregon, which simply launched disappointing statistics on drug habit, therapy, and overdoses following one 12 months of drug decriminalization in that state. Summarized, the state didn’t expertise the uptick in habit therapy or the downward development in overdoses that it hoped decriminalization measures would result in.

It’s virtually sure {that a} program that doesn’t incarcerate drug customers but which compels them to hunt therapy could be the perfect compromise. Such an method would nonetheless put forth the notion that drug use just isn’t okay, however it will achieve this from the attitude that addicts should search therapy and get higher. It could be a compassionate but agency method.

Maybe leaving some penalties in place however altering or lessening them if therapy is accomplished is the most effective route attainable. It walks the center floor and neither legalizes medication nor normalizes their use, nor does it criminalize individuals for having an habit. In Oregon, the current poll measure to decriminalize medication appears to not be working as a result of there was no incentive put in place to compel addicts to hunt therapy if apprehended. Relatively, an method like Oregon’s mannequin however with a greater system for directing addicts into therapy could be the reply.

Packages that Result in Therapy and Restoration are the Reply

It’s vital to have a nuanced dialogue about how, on the one hand, closely criminalizing habit just isn’t the right reply, however neither is blanket legalization with no packages in place for serving to addicts, and neither is merely incentivizing therapy as part of the repercussions of utilizing medication. Relatively, a compromise that reduces prison penalties for drug possession and use whereas compelling these apprehended with medication to search therapy is probably going a greater method.

Maybe probably the most workable resolution could be to arrange diversion packages that might ship drug offenders to therapy, fairly than jail. Such a mannequin has been applied with some success in locations like Seattle, Washington and Baltimore, Maryland.

Habit just isn’t an issue that goes away, even for individuals who attempt very laborious to cease utilizing medication. If you realize somebody who’s utilizing medication, please do the whole lot you may to get them assist.


Reviewed an edited by Claire Pinelli; ICAADC, ICCS, LADC, RAS, MCAP, LCDC


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *