Can You Spot a Lie?

Can You Spot a Lie?


How good are you at recognizing a liar? Most individuals suppose they’re above common, however the analysis clearly exhibits that we are not any higher than 50-50—a flip of the coin, pure probability—at detecting lies. We could also be higher at recognizing the lies of somebody we all know effectively, at the very least we’d prefer to be, however once more there’s no proof to help this, only a pious want.

There’s an assumption in my query that the best way you notice a liar is to detect one thing within the non-verbal habits that offers away the lie. The phrases say one factor, the physique language one other. And when these two “conversations” are at variance, we at all times consider the physique language. Once you ask your associate if she’s upset about one thing, you don’t spend plenty of time parsing the phrases “I’m superb”; slightly, you pay attention for the tone of voice, search for the folded arms, and so forth, to see what the non-verbal dialog is telling you. If all of that’s adverse, you assume she’s not superb.

There’s nothing significantly outstanding about this habits. All of us spend a good period of time detecting how individuals round us really feel by the clues they ship us by way of physique language, and shortly decide what we expect their actual intent is.


Supply: Thirdman/Pexels

And given how necessary intent is to human conversations and connections, you’d suppose we’d be higher at figuring out it normally. That there’s a virtually foolproof method to detect a lie specifically, then, comes as a little bit of a shock. And it has nothing to do with physique language.

It’s generally known as the Reid Approach, after the previous Chicago police officer and psychologist who developed it. His first well-known conviction was overturned when the person that Reid bought to admit turned out to be harmless (one other individual confessed), however the method was established and it’s nonetheless in use.

The method doesn’t use physique language in any respect. Reasonably, it includes assuming that the individual below suspicion is responsible and asks a sequence of questions designed to lull the obvious perpetrator into feeling that the questioner is on his or her aspect. “Did you intend this or did it simply occur?”

Not a great method to make use of on these close to and expensive to us, as a result of its best weak point is that it results in false confessions, and presumably asking an extended sequence of questions in regards to the incident that the one you love is denying wouldn’t really feel like a relational method to act. The actual motive that we’re not superb at figuring out lies and liars is that we make an assumption of fact with the individuals we love, more often than not—and that’s a great factor. Most of us do inform the reality more often than not in regards to the stuff that issues in our lives, and that’s how human intimacy and belief are imagined to work. Little white lies (“no, that doesn’t make you look fats!”) are the roadkill on the freeway of fact, the highway all of us need to be on.

That does make us weak to lies, however it’s nonetheless a greater method to function than to imagine everyone seems to be mendacity to us on a regular basis. That may trigger manner an excessive amount of friction in {our relationships}.

Is there something that we are able to take away from the Reid Approach that’s helpful in our on a regular basis lives, and that may enhance our potential to identify lies when it issues? Simply this: assume that our physique language-reading expertise are solely common, and as an alternative ask a query or two designed to permit the occasion in query extra simply to confess to the lie. The questions ought to assume guilt after which ask the way it felt. “Was it enjoyable to cover the empty brownie pan?” Pay attention onerous to the reply and what it might inform you. And don’t count on very a lot. We’re higher off being sometimes fooled than eternally suspicious.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *